The flaw here is assuming that society agrees. It appears that way outwardly because people/experts who disagree are silenced. They aren't given a platform to speak or dissent as are Fauci and Sanjay Gupta. Doctors like Geert Vanden Bossche and Sucharit Bhakdi who have a different opinion than Fauci are not allowed to speak. Doctors like Scott Jansen and Vladimir Zelenko have been silenced for months. There is no way to come to an agreement when the dissenters are silenced. There is no way to create trust in a "utilitarian product" when there is only one narrative and no discussion around that product.
Informed consent cannot happen when dissenting opinions are de-platformed and villanized.